Replacement Decision in Bond - CA Final SFM

New Bond will be issued at the place of old bond.

When bonds/debentures are redeemed before maturity then the redemption will be at premium. Premium paid on redemption of bond is called call premium.

Premium on redemption (Call Premium) will expenses for company i.e. outflow for the company and it saves tax (Tax Shield on Call Premium Paid) i.e. Inflow for the company.

Steps for Calculation of Net Present Value (NPV)

A) Initial Incremental Cash out Flow
Redemption of Old Bond                                                                    XXX
Issue of New Bond                                                                              (XXX)
Call Premium on Redemption                                                              XXX
New Floatation Cost                                                                            XXX
Tax Shield on Call Premium                                                                (XXX)
Tax Shield on Unamortized floatation Cost Written off on Old Bond (XXX) 
Initial Incremental Cash Outflow                                                      XXX


B) Incremental Annual Cash Inflow

i) Net Saving on Interest Payments
Interest on Old Bond                                                                           XXX
Interest on New Bond                                                                          (XXX)
Saving in Interest                                                                                 XXX
Less: - Tax on Saving in Interest                                                         (XXX)
Net Saving in Interest                                                                        XXX

ii) Incremental Tax Shield on Floatation Cost
Tax Shield on New Floatation Written off                                           XXX
Tax Shield on old Floatation Written off                                                         (XXX)
Initial Incremental Tax Shield on Floatation Cost                            XXX

Net Annual Incremental Cash Inflow                                                            i) +ii)


C) Incremental Terminal Value (Cash Outflow)

Redemption of New Bond after Maturity                                                        XXX
Redemption of old Bond after Maturity                                                           (XXX)
Net Incremental Terminal Value (Cash Outflow)                             XXX

D) NPV
Present Value of Cash Inflows                                                                        XXX
Present Value of Cash Outflows                                                                      (XXX)
NPV                                                                                                    XXX

Decision: -

If NPV is Positive then replace the existing bond with New Bond.

If NPV is Negative then do not replace the existing bond with New Bond.


Explanation to Floating Cost on Issue and Discount on Issue: -

Let us understand with an example

Example: - ABC Company has Following Details: -
Revenue                                              Rs. 1000000
Floating Cost (Old Bond)                     Rs. 400000 will be written off for 10 Years.
Floating Cost (New Bond)                   Rs. 600000 will be written off for 10 Years.
Other Expenses                                    Rs. 500000
Tax Rate                                              50% Ignore Cess and Surcharge for Understanding Purpose
Solution:-
Situation I: - Company doesn’t have floatation Cost to Written off
Situation II: - Company has floatation Cost on old Bond to Written off
Situation III: - Company issued new bond in place of old bond, it means new floatation Cost to Written off in Place of old Floatation cost 


Particulars
Situation I
(Amount in Rs.)
Situation II
(Amount in Rs.)
Situation III
(Amount in Rs.)
Revenue
Expenses
Floatation Cost on old Bond
Floatation Cost on  new Bond

Taxable Income

Tax
1000000
500000
-
-

500000

250000
1000000
500000
40000
-

460000

230000
1000000
500000
-
60000

440000

220000

Conclusion: - By Comparing Situation I & II we conclude Floatation Cost written off Saves Tax (Tax Shield) which is treated as Inflow, Tax Shield = Flotation Cost * Tax Rate.

By Comparing Situation II & III we conclude Floatation Cost Written off on New Bond will saves but Floatation Cost Not Written off on Old Bond will Increase Tax Expenses for Company it means Incremental Tax Saving (Tax Shield) will equal to Tax Saving on Incremental Floatation Cost Written off. Hence, Incremental Tax Shield (Incremental Inflow) = (Floatation Cost Written Off on New Bond –Floatation Cost Written Off on Old Bond)*Tax Rate.


Note: - Same treatment will be done in case of Discount on Issue of  Bond/debenture.

To Like Us Click Here

No comments:

Post a Comment